Magnolia (1999) by Paul Thomas Anderson
In Film Art (1990), in most sequences, the film sound is clearly able to be divided whether the sound is for the narrative circle or the non narrative circle. However, some films make the sound vague to distinguish if the sound is for the narrative circle or the non narrative circle. Films use the audiences’ habits to specify the source of the film sound and play with their expectations, Bordwell, D implies. (p351)
Usually the film with a narrator has both the sounds for the narrative circle and the non narrative circle. When the narrator is speaking in the film, it makes the audiences out of the narrative story for a while, and when it is off narration, the dialogues and the film sound takes the audiences into the story.
Magnolia is an American human drama. A successful producer facing to death and his son feuding for a long time, a popular TV emcee having a cancer, his daughter having a grudge against him, and a police officer having crush on her, a generous boy who still relies on his past achievement, the film depicts 24 hours of various people living in LA.
The film sound of Magnolia, however is quite ambiguous for viewers. In some parts of the film, some characters are shown in various places and sing ‘Save me’ by Aimee Mann quietly. The song starts from Claudia, even though each character are different places and must not be able to hear Claudia singing, following the cut of Claudia singing, the screen moves to another character singing the following the song. When Claudia is singling, the viewers may think the song is from off screen, because Claudia has been listening to that song before singing, but later the screen shows each character starts singing in turns. The sound effect there tells us that these characters are on the similar boundary having an agony.
Magnolia also includes an orchestration of characters’ lines. In some sequences, the screen shows the cuts with dizzying speed to show each character speaking their lines, which leads they are on the verge of unable to deal with their agony. The characters in Magnolia severally repeat that even though they forget their past, the past never forgets them. The film also replies this sentence, and progresses both the past and the present simultaneously.
Bibliography
Bordwell, D. Thompson, K. Film Art : an introduction New York ; London : McGraw-Hill, (1990) pp 351